If you’re looking for the best pizza in Lake Arrowhead, California, you’re half way there. We’ve got a short list of the best pizza joints ranked by the category that’s most important to you. If you’re in a hurry, need a delivery, or prefer to sit down with beer and pie to soak in a night at Lake Arrowhead, there’s a place for you.
Slice Your Pizza by Category
Quickest Pizza Delivery on the Mountain
Sometimes you just need a quick meal at home. If your primary driver for selecting a pizza restaurant is convenience, you do have options. Only two of Lake Arrowhead’s pizza restaurants provide a delivery service.
- Domino’s Pizza [profile]
The king of delivery pizza reigns on the mountain as the quickest way to get a pizza. The chain’s reliability is baked into the business model. If you need a pizza, and you need it fast, Domino’s is a best option for delivery. - Loueddie’s Pizza [profile]
You must be patient if you desire your pizza delivered from Loueddie’s. But it’s totally worth it. The pizzeria is focused on the artisan nature of its product and the atmosphere at the physical location. So much love can’t be baked as quickly in a small brick oven pizza.
Lake Arrowhead Village Pizza previously delivered. However, the business discontinued delivery after the 2023 snow storm. New insurance requirements have limited them to pick-up and dining room options only.
Closest Pizza Restaurant to Lake Arrowhead
If you prefer to focus your time near the water or find yourself in the Lake Arrowhead Village, there’s a pizza option for you. This list uses the village as ground zero to determine the closest pizza restaurant to Lake Arrowhead.
- Lake Arrowhead Village Pizza [profile] (0 miles)
If it’s the lake you came for, it’s the lake you shall see at Lake Arrowhead Pizzeria. Their massive outdoor patio provides rooftop views of the water. It’s a fantastic way to dine near other shopping and entertainment venues. - Loueddie’s Pizza [profile] (1.9 miles)
The restaurant is located right along Highway 18. That’s convenient for pick up purposes. If you’ll be staying, there is no lake view. But the outdoor deck and beer garden give guests an amazing dining experience among the trees. It’s a second-to-none, eclectic atmosphere. - Puglia Italian Restaurant [profile] (2.4 miles)
In the Blue Jay region of Lake Arrowhead, you’ll find this gem of restaurant. They serve exceptional Italian cuisine, and Puglia is easy to find. There’s a dining and outdoor dining area with attentive service. - Osorio Brother’s Pizza [profile] (3.6 miles)
If you’re looking for a meal on your way out, Osorio Brother’s may be a good option. It’s on Highway 18 on your way out of Lake Arrowhead, adjacent to a gas station and convenient store.
Best Tasting Pizza in the Lake Arrowhead Area
If you define the best pizza in Lake Arrowhead by taste, this list is for you. The mountain has pie-in-the-sky level grub, and this this list includes the super supreme leaders.
- Puglia Italian Restaurant [profile]
Fresh ingredients and an award-winning chef come together to create an amazing creation. This is real Napoletana style pizza from the home country. Puglia Italian Restaurant offers an exceptional dining experience and menu of Italian cuisine. They use fresh ingredients to hand craft beautiful and delicious pizzas. Find out why Chef Antonello Zito was recently named Italian Champion of Pizza Napoletana. - Loueddie’s Pizza [profile]
A close second is the thin crust pizza at Loueddie’s. Their masterful pizzas are fire-roasted to perfection in a small-batch oven with fresh ingredients. It’s an elegant mashup of New York Style pizza and mountain vibes. The buildings and the oven are aged to perfection, resulting in a one-of-a-kind pizza pie that cannot be duplicated.
The tie-breaker for these two is atmosphere. Both have unique and memorable dine-in experiences. Puglia’s offers a slightly more formal dining room with table service, and Loueddie’s more dressed down, order-at-the-counter experience. You decide who makes the best pizza in Lake Arrowhead.
Most Exceptional Atmosphere for Lake Arrowhead Pizza
A restaurant’s atmosphere can make a massive impact on your dining experience. If you’re going out for pizza in Lake Arrowhead, you have two amazing options to choose from. Do you prefer beer or wine with your pizza?
- Loueddie’s Pizza [profile]
From the street view, you can tell Loueddie’s is a place with years of character. If the cabin-like charm and eclectic decor don’t reel you in, the downstairs beer garden will. Enjoy craft beers and other beverages inside or on the wood patio under the massive pine trees and toasty patio heaters. Settle in and get comfortable. When busy, your wait for a pizza can take an hour. But you really don’t mind in this pine tree pizza paradise. - Puglia Italian Restaurant [profile]
Fresh ingredients and an award-winning chef come together to create an amazing creation. This is real Napoletana style pizza from the home country. Diners are treated to family-run restaurant service. These folks care about their customers, and they care about their food. You feel at home dining inside or on their beautiful deck.
Directory of Lake Arrowhead Pizzerias
Domino’s Pizza
26517 CA-18, Rimforest, CA 92378
1-909-336-1255
Delivery/Takeout
Website: dominos.com
Menu: dominos.com
Crust: Hand tossed, pan, thin crust
Toppings: Classic (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, etc.)
Ambiance: Not applicable
Price range: Low to moderate
Unique offerings: Quick delivery
View: Not applicable
Outdoor seating: Not applicable
Live music/entertainment: Not applicable
Lake Arrowhead Village Pizza
28200 Hwy 189, Unit 04-140, Lake Arrowhead, CA 92352
1-909-337-0723
Takeout/Dine In
Website: lakearrowheaddeli.com
Menu: chownow.com
Crust: Regular crust
Toppings: Classic (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, etc.)
Ambiance: Traditional American pizzeria, busy, kid-friendly
Price range: Moderate
Unique offerings: Arcade for kids, rooftop patio with lake view
View: Lake view in the village
Outdoor seating: Rooftop patio with umbrellas
Live music/entertainment: Not applicable
Loueddie’s Pizza & Brewery
28561 CA-18, Skyforest, CA 92385
1-909-336-4931
Delivery/Takeout/Dine In
Website: loueddies.com
Menu: loueddies.com/menu
Crust: Thin crust, New York-style
Toppings: Classic (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom), gourmet (artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, truffle oil), vegan/vegetarian options
Ambiance: Cozy, eclectic, woodsy, casual
Price range: Moderate
Unique offerings: Special pizzas, wood-fired oven, beer garden, gourmet salads
View: Nestled in the trees
Outdoor seating: Wood deck with heating
Live music/entertainment: Occasionally – call ahead
Puglia Italian Restaurant
26848 Hwy 189, Blue Jay, CA 92317
1-909-744-8859
Delivery/Takeout/Dine In
Website: pugliaitalianrestaurant.com
Menu: pugliaitalianrestaurant.com/menu
Crust: Napolitan-style
Toppings: Margherita, spciy salami, spring, prosciutto cotto, romana, and palmina
Ambiance: Refined but lake casual, feels like home with family-owned service
Price range: Moderate to high
Unique offerings: Award-winning pizza, other excellent Italian options
View: Not applicable
Outdoor seating: Wood deck with heating
Live music/entertainment: Occasionally – call ahead
Osorio Brother’s
26545 CA-18, Rimforest, CA 92378
1-909-744-9808
Takeout/Dine In
Website: None
Menu: None
Crust: Pan
Toppings: Classic (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, etc.)
Ambiance: Simple, relaxed, unpretentious, kid-friendly
Price range: Moderate
Unique offerings: Broad menu serving food all day
View: Not applicable
Outdoor seating: Not applicable
Live music/entertainment: Not applicable
The San Bernardino Mountains have some terrific pizza restaurants, and Lake Arrowhead features some of the best. During your stay at the Serenity Pines Lake Arrowhead cabin, we recommend you find some time to enjoy one of these pizzerias.